Homemade ornaments
I remember from my childhood candy cane reindeer with antlers made from pipe cleaners in twisty red and white, and cute little walnut shells stuffed with roving and a bead for the head of baby Jesus in the manger. But honestly, I don't remember homemade ornaments being 'beautiful'. They were the ones that brought back memories of "oh you remember when you were 4 and you brought this home from preschool?" They didn't make people stop and ask "That's beautiful! Where did you get that?"
This Waldorf star that Alex made is a current favorite of mine. It is about 2 inches wide and my origami master of a teen has made 5 of them to hang on the tree now. They are just stunning! I had to take them down and cover them in glitter Mod Podge so they will last forever, because they are just too precious to not keep!
This one is a bit more homemade looking. It is made from recycled sweaters. I love it though! It looks like something you would find at a craft fair, doesn't it?
The most homemade looking one we have made this year has been the beeswax ones... but they are just SO pretty on the tree!

Comments
@ Frannie - Thank you, my dear! That is so good to hear. I have had quite the day with my teen so it is always nice to know that somewhere my life looks pulled together and pleasant. <3
@ Silver Sisters - Oh I will have to go check it out! Yes, they do evolve as they get older. Alex made those all on his own for the first time last year and I was just blown away! They were from the scraps that I was cutting off for the bigger stars we have above the nature table... My sweet recycler. ;)
@ Tanivee - There is a link to a tute here:
http://goddesshobbies.blogspot.com/2009/12/hanging-paper-stars.html